What do we mean by ‘dialogue’?
- By ‘dialogue’ we mean engagement between people with different approaches to life to build mutual understanding, identify common ground and, where it makes sense, engage in shared action.
- We do not mean failing to challenge ideas and activities we believe to be harmful, or failing to recognise areas of disagreement. Mutual understanding means understanding differences as well as common ground. If dialogue achieves no more than box-ticking, photo-opportunities, or mutual admiration, it is of little value.
- Debate, unlike dialogue, is adversarial, with each side trying to persuade an audience to adopt one rival view and ultimately to win. We participate in many debates but recognise that they are not the only way to engage.
- ‘Interfaith dialogue’ is an established term often used by religious people. Taken literally, it excludes people of no faith. But over half the people in Britain, including all humanists, do not identify with any ‘faith’. And in practice, and for many years, humanists have worked constructively alongside religious people both at a national level and in local ‘interfaith’ groups. In some cases these groups have changed their names or amended their terms of reference to reflect their inclusive approach. ‘Interfaith’ bodies that are open to representatives of many religions but deliberately exclude the non-religious can seem like – and be – ‘circling the wagons’ rather than coming to terms with the changes taking place in British society.
Why does Humanists UK engage in dialogue?
- We want to see a world where everyone lives cooperatively on the basis of shared human values, respect for human rights, and concern for future generations. We believe this entails viewing people who have different views from ours first-and-foremost as fellow human beings, rather than ‘The Other’. That does not mean failing to argue for what we believe is right; but it does mean listening, understanding, looking at evidence, treating people fairly, and avoiding ill-informed generalisations. It also means being willing to work with others of different beliefs for the common good.
- Living cooperatively is essential for the type of secular state we want to see, where the human right to freedom of thought and expression is guaranteed, where there is no religious privilege, and where everyone is treated equally regardless of religion or belief.
- As well as understanding others, we want to help religious people understand humanists and Humanism.
- By supporting groups to take part in effective dialogues of their own. See our ‘Guideline for humanists engaging in small group dialogue with religious people‘ for more information.
Why is dialogue important now?
In terms of religion, philosophy, and worldviews, British society is going through a profound change:
- Far more people say they do not belong to any religion. The British Social Attitudes survey has been run annually since 1983. When asked “Which religion or denomination do you consider yourself as belonging to?” in 1983, 32% of people said they did not belong to a religion. In 2015 it was 49%, and in 2016, 53% – a change that is even more pronounced in younger people.
- The mix and religiosity of those who do say they belong to a religion is changing. There are now many fewer Anglicans (down from 40% in 1983 to 17% in 2015, with a weighting towards older age groups). The population of Catholics has remained relatively constant at 9%, sustained by immigration. The big growth has been in the number of Pentecostals and other non-denominational Christians (3% in 1983, 12% in 2015). The proportion of Muslims has also grown (1% in 1983, 4% in 2015, weighted towards younger age groups), with a big diversity of types of Islam among the British Muslim population reflecting both their varied origins and global trends.
Given world events and this complex national background, issues relating directly or indirectly to religious and non-religious worldviews have a higher profile in Britain now than at any time in living memory. Too often the discourse is hijacked by hardliners or characterised by uninformed generalisations and dehumanising “us versus them” narratives – the opposite of a humanist perspective. Dialogue can be a powerful enabler for people from diverse backgrounds directly to encounter and understand those with different views. Humanists have a constructive role to play in making that happen for the good of individuals and of wider society.
How humanists can and do engage in dialogue
Many aspects of Humanists UK’s work involves engagement with people from religious backgrounds. For example, we work with the Network for Pastoral, Spiritual and Religious Care in Health, the All Party Parliamentary Group on International Freedom of Religion or Belief, the Accord Coalition for Inclusive Education, and the Cutting Edge Consortium. Our Director of Public Affairs and Policy is Treasurer of the Religious Education Council of England and Wales, a group bringing together representatives from many religion and belief organisations which share the desire to promote high quality education about religion, beliefs and ethics in schools. Members of the Non-Religious Pastoral Support Network work closely with religious people in chaplaincy and pastoral support teams in hospitals and prisons. Humanists often speak in schools as members of multi-belief panels, and our Dialogue Officer is involved in a wide range of interactions with people of faith, including events such as:
There are humanist members of many local Standing Advisory Councils on Religious Education (SACREs), and faith and belief forums throughout England, Wales and Northern Ireland. And there have been many examples of specific local dialogue activities, such as this Catholic/humanist interaction “Careless Talk”.
If you have any comments or want to know more about our dialogue activities, please email email@example.com